The mistakes of Twilight

Dear LTTers,

Thank you so much for your congratulations & sweet words regarding our 10 month anniversary yesterday. We have a confession that we’d like to share in the form of “texts from last night” between Moon & UC:

Text from Moon: “Just wrapped up my ’10 month anniversary/10 things I love about Twi’ post- getting in bed- wouldn’t it be funny if we calculated wrong and our 10 month anniversary is next week?
Text from UC
: “We’d look like the biggest idiots”
Text from Moon:
“Umm…. I just calculated. Can you double check my math”
Text from UC: “Yep. Just double checked.
Happy 9 month anniversary”

Oops. I know we seem perfect, but we’re not. For example, we miss things. Once there was a picture of Big Daddy with a dabble of ketchup down the front of his shirt. We missed an opportunity to photo-shop him in a Heintz ketchup ad. And one time Moon said “I bet it’s hard to be Jacob Black” and I forgot to say “that’s what she said.” It’s hard to be perfect all the time. We try. But we sometimes fail. Even we make mistakes.

So in honor of our 9 month anniversary (yesterday) and to continue our new fond love of making lists, here are 9 mistakes from the Twilight world:

1. The Bandslam & PUSH previews on the Twilight DVD

(that you cannot fast forward through- bastards) Summit thought they were being sneaky, making us watch those previews before we got to see Robward’s beautiful face. Little did they know that I just made copies of the DVD, got rid of the previews and sold them illegally on the black market. In your Face Summit. Just kidding. What I really did was press Play; Go make some popcorn; Pour myself some bubbly; Walk back into the room; Groan that Vanessa Hudgens was STILL on the screen; Go pee; Put on my PJs; Come back. Movie time. In your face, Summit.

Dear Stephenie, This outfit is not hot Love, us

Dear Stephenie, This outfit is not hot Love, us

2. Edward’s taste of music, clothing & bedding in the books

WestFriend: Why did Stephenie make Edward so lame when it comes to music taste. Umm…hi. He hates the 60’s and 70’s? The BEST time for music ever? And he LOVES the 50’s and some of the 80’s? It has bothered me so bad.
: SMeyer is an enigma. Cause the 60s ruled the music scene. But the real questions are: Why does she make Edward wear sleeveless button ups and have black and gold brocade bedding?? These things I’ve never understood.

3. Including Perry Farrell and Collective Soul on the Soundtrack

Dear Summit,

It’s clear from your marketing that you are unaware that anyone other than 12 to really immature 15 1/2 year olds like the Twilight saga, so why in the world would you force Alexandra Patsavas (who made Death Cab for Cutie & Imogen Heap household names, so I know it wasn’t her doing) to include an old washed up rocker looking for a comeback & a band that no one has thought of since 1995 on the soundtrack?

4. The EW magazine cover that ended the careers of a photographer & editor


I just need one.more.hit. Buy my apple?

And if the photographer & editors weren’t fired, they should’ve been- or maybe even hung. Who told them Twilight was about methed-up teen addicts who sell their last piece of food- an apple- to buy enough meth so they could ceremoniously commit a joint suicide/OD and spend eternity together listening to Collective Soul? EW Fail

Follow the jump for the rest of the mistakes!

5. Bella’s trendy outfits

LTR friends Brooke, Marta & StageManageThis had a heated debate about this ‘mistake.’ Coincidentally they were sitting at Pacific Pizza in Forks. Or maybe not so coincidentally. Cuz I hear Forks kinda blows in the food-area, and if you’re looking for Pizza in Forks, Pacific Pizza is probably your only option. Brooke argued that Bella was a bit too fashionable in the movie, especially towards the end. She says, “Book Bella wore simple shirts- she was more of a t-shirt and jeans kind of girl. She’s supposed to dress simply- no big jewelry, no romantic tops (other than the blue blouse – which reminds me that no teenager actually says blouse). By Summit making Bella fashionable rather than plain, they ended up pushing the limits with Alice, who looks like a closet threw up on her.”

6. The Death of a fake-lesbianship

Oh Kristen. Oh Nikki. How could you? You had such a beautiful thing. All the hand-holding, the skipping, the smiling. Now it’s Nikki working out 24/7 with a new woman on her arm & Kristen method acting like a rocker, mullet-ed real lesbian. I miss the days when you acted like the girls from T.A.T.U. and made us laugh with your innocent giggles, cutesy matching clothes & shoes and shared love of the marijuana leaf. Things will never be the same…… Never….

7. The almost re-casting of Jacob Black


Both Legal in Georgia

While Michael Copon might be legal in states other than Georgia & his washboard abs are not a sore site for the eyes, this dude is not Jacob & the fact that he was considered as a replacement for even a second is a Twilight mistake bigger than Bella wearing a khaki skirt when she meets the Cullen’s for the first time (seriously Steph? khaki? Where’d she find it? Old Navy stopped making those in ’96) We will forever be in debt to Chris Weitz for keeping Taycob in the picture and providing us with ample opportunity for Chris Hansen to knock upon our doors.

8. Killing off Buttcrack Santa

It might seem more appropriate to call the introduction of Buttcrack Santa a Twilight mistake, but no! I’d never think that. Buttcrack Santa will be forever embedded in our minds as a icon- a pillar of the Forks made-up community. And as pointed out one time by a beautiful commenter who called Moon & I “stupid idiots” for not knowing that Buttcrack Santa is a type of beer, his ‘play-on-words’ name is further proof of Summit not knowing their audience. In addition to thinking only 12 to really immature 15 1/2 year olds love the Twilight series, apparently they also think their 70something creepy, old next door neighbors who still have boxes of a discontinued beer from the Korean War days, will love the movie as well. All I know is that we will truly miss our ol’ friend, his buttcrack, the little bottles (filled with Buttcrack Santa beer? He died, so we’ll never be able to ask him) and his songs about mamas & kitties. RIP, Buttcrack Santa. RIP*

9. The Midnight Sun Leak

I saved the worst for last. This was a dark day for Twilight fans. Well, it was a light day for 12 chapters and 6 hours while I ignored household chores, my husband & stayed in my PJs with my lap top in my bed, but afterwards…. ohhh the agony! Sometimes I wish I never read it. How could it end right before the Meadow scene? Is Steph trying to kill us with the anticipation? And THEN the drama that happened after….. the letter from Stephenie, her later saying she was kinda kidding about the letter and then all these months that have followed. All these months without knowing what Edward thinks. What does he really think when he sees Bella in that khaki skirt? Or is he the one who snuck it into her dresser drawer after he found it in the Cullen house basement in a tub marked “Clothes Alice bought from Old Navy outlet store as an act of kindness so no one would ever be caught in public wearing them?” We’ll never know. Or maybe we will but we’ll have to wait, praying every day that Stephenie decides to share with us the rest of her brilliant story about Edward. Stephenie: I have to confess I recently read the fanfiction The Office. This is how I am now picturing Edward. I will forever picture Edward this way unless you give me back virginal Edward in the form of a finished book. I mean it. Your Edward doesn’t do Bella on the top of his desk. The Edward currently in my mind does. If you don’t like that. Fix it.


What “mistakes” did I miss from Twilight? There are SO many…!

Also, Moon & I laughed SO hard when we realized OUR big mistake. We realized it early yesterday morning… so we had to read your comments all day about our 10 month anniversary, bracing for someone to do the math and call us out in the comments! I’m take total blame for the counting mistake. But I’m gonna blame it on Summit. Cuz it’s fun. And That’s Normal.

The Forum never makes mistakes
LTR does though…. celebrate our NINE MONTH anniversary over there!

*Someone did call us stupid idiots for not knowing that Buttcrack Santa is a beer. Apparently Google is also a stupid idiot, because they’re unaware that it’s a beer too. I totes made up the part about the Korean War but like to believe it’s true. I have a fond vision in my mind of handsome sailors sippin’ on a cold Buttcrack Santa in the canteen, chowing down on kimchee.

  • Kristin

    Also in the book at prom Bella was wearing a high heel Alice picked out for her & not sneakers & tights! Just a terrible outfit all together in the movie!

    • blackrose

      Not to mention that she could barely walk when she went to prom, but in the movie she makes that moon boot look like a regular shoe she is walking in!

  • Bobina

    EW shoot.. UBER FAIL! I saw it at Barnes and Noble and almost threw up in mouth and yelled (to myself) what the eff is that? HOPING that was not what they were going to look like in the movie.

  • Jeanne

    HAPPY 9th Ladies. keep making me laugh everymorning, only way I can keep sane when I get into work, cause who really works when you can blog and stalk on Rob all day!

    On a differnt note and I know Im late, but the DVD from target is the best bang for your buck CAUSE not only do you get the extra features but you also get FREE downloads of the movie and extra from iTunes for your iPhone or iPod! So I get access to Rob anytime of the day via my phone =)

    • Tasha

      {{{{running to Target}}}}}

  • “Clothes Alice bought from Old Navy outlet store as an act of kindness so no one would ever be caught in public wearing them?”
    Hahahaha. She sure is something, our little Alice…

    I agree with everything. Especially Edward’s taste in music. How can someone not like the sixties? And we’re not talking about anyone here, we’re talking Edward fucking Cullen. Feel sorry Stephenie. Feel really sorry about that! In my happy place Edward went to Woodstock 1969 and adores The Beatles.
    Btw The Remastered Albums are out! Whiiiii! Edward is so buying them.

    Biggest book mistake: Renesmee.

    • Tasha

      Renesmee! Yes! Epic Fail. There are no words for that.
      The “fade to black”. My god!! Dry hump your fine ass vampire boyfriend for three books, and then get pregnant the first time you hit it. FAIL. FAIL. FAIL.

      I still cant look at feathers without getting a smirk on my face.

      Edward would so love the Beatles and the Stones

      • “Dry hump your fine ass vampire boyfriend for three books, and then get pregnant the first time you hit it. FAIL. FAIL. FAIL”

        Hahaha. You should check out this creeptastic Renesmee’s Lullaby video I discovered yesterday. It is unintentionally telling the story of a man suckered into fatherhood:

        Watch Edwards face at 0.26. You just know that man is NOT changing the diaper.

        • Shleeeigh

          MY GOD there are some creepy things out there.

        • nearly22

          That was so creepy! ARGH!

  • Jess W

    “apparently they also think their 70something creepy, old next door neighbors who still have boxes of a discontinued beer from the Korean War days, will love the movie as well.” That really HAS to have been their thought process. Really Summit? Really?!

    I’m still cracking up. Another fantastic post, love you guys!

  • katiebird

    I totally agree that Midnight Sun stopping where it did is a cruel joke…I think that she has it finished somewhere, with the Twilight Sage “guide” that she is finishing.
    My favorite fan fiction Edward is “The List”. Definitely will change my reaction to some scenes in Eclipse, when the movie comes out. Fills in the blanks, where Stepanie does not go to or touch. Pun intended…

    • Elizabeth

      their just waiting for all the movies to be made and once they realise they can’t get any more money out of us then she’ll release it and make millions all over again.

  • tryshlynn

    I’m glad to see I wasn’t the only one going WTF with some of the clothing choices. That sleeveless button up shirt? Really? I didn’t think you could buy them that way, I thought you had to rip the sleeves off yourself.

  • MidnightSin

    Did anyone else think they flubbed the part when Edward scoops her up the first time and “flys” through the woods to the mountain top…Rob justs kinda drops her and KStew is once again expressionless….not like in shock or OMG…..her hair isn’t even mussed…I’m just thinking that if I had just had the same experience (and yes I would volunteer) I would have had quite a different reaction to the whole thing!!!

  • g_row

    I really hope that SM still reads this. Mostly b/c she NEEDS to finish Midnight Sun. I don’t know what she is thinking, not following thru. EPOV is my fav, and MS was better than Twi. I think esp for grown-ass women like myself who neglected raising their children just to read her books. Ante up, Steph. (Tho BB is not such a bad version of Edward to have floatin around in your head!)

    • SassyPants

      ” I think esp for grown-ass women like myself who neglected raising their children just to read her books”

      I would give you a double thumbs up for this if I could!

  • Ishla

    What a brilliant way to waste an hour. keep it up ladies.

    • SassyPants

      One hour? I’m working on at least two cumulatively today.

  • Sianna

    I knew it!
    Yesterday, I did do a double take when you said it was the ten month anniversary. I really did think it was less than that, I just didnt say anything.
    I remember reading some older posts from december, and it just didnt add up.

  • Where is that girl that called me & moon Stupid idiots for not knowing buttcrack santa is a beer.. i wanna know if it really is….

    • Jaybird

      Is it a microbrew? I think my hubbster drank it once and said it did taste like buttcrack. I think it came in a pack of microbrews from Cost Plus. Not sure. I will ask the hubs.

      Oh, and I am not the girl who called you “Stupid idiots”! Just to clarify! 😉

  • Bleriana

    Hey UC,
    where can I read that Fanfic of yours ?

    • wellll it’s not ‘mine’ but if you google ‘the office’ and ‘twilight’ you’ll find it:)

  • Mel

    This totally reminds me of the horrid dinner scene where Edward wears a cream colored sweater. A sweater?! Oh, so horrid.

    • Katie S

      Is that the scene where they dress in the same outfit?? FAIL. Sorry, SM… love you.

  • lovemesomecullens

    I just keep picturing Wal-Mart Bella. With her blue “blouse and Khaki skirt”. All that blue and khaki
    just screams wal mart employee.

    And as for the brocade fabric, well you can google it…

    Love the site ladies!

  • tby789

    Ok, being that I write The Office, I think I love you a little. Ok, a lot.

    I nodded, gasped and lmao while I read this. Great job.


    • themoonisdown

      is it super nerdy that im kinda a little bit more than giddy that TBY789 is commenting on our site?!!! ps i just had an at length discussion about the office this morning! LOVE YOUR FACE and YOUR BB!!! SMOOCHES you are always welcome here!!

      • Katie S

        First SM and now tby789?! This blog is a hot bed of Twi-magic. I’m convinced either UC or moon will be propositioned by Rob soon. Or at least buttcrack Santa.

  • Nine months. Long enough to have a baby. Unless of course you’re breeding vampire spawn, in which case you could have like eight of them by now, and they’d all be potty trained.

  • AmyAlmost

    Oh thank god, I thought I was the only one. I nearly put down the whole series when Edward – this big music fan – hated 60’s and 70’s music.

    • Katie S

      I can picture Edward listening to Depeche Mode and The Cure all the time.

  • Jaybird

    Here is a website that has the “Santa’s butt” Microbrew. I was going to email it to you, but then I got all nervous and thought, I can’t email someone famous! I am such a dork 😉

    Again, I am not the one that called you stupid! This probably is not even the right beer, but this may be what she was talking about!?

  • Calliope

    Edward didn’t like the music of the 60s and 70s because it was all about Sex and Drugs ….. you can’t understand what you ain’t gettin.

    • Tasha


  • Pingback: Twitter Trackbacks for The mistakes of Twilight « Letters to Twilight [] on

  • sft

    Tha-ah-nk you for the khaki mention. Here I was imagining I could be Bella and then she puts on this heinous, stiff tent-like skirt (khaki isn’t exactly flowy) and it stops me dead in my tracks. Up until that point Stephenie didn’t give away the fact she was a thirty something writing on behalf of a teen, but that was a giveaway.

    I really hate it when authors give you a wardrobe malfunction like that. Has anyone read If I Stay? The same thing happened with the main character on her date, and I think if I haven’t blocked it completely from my memory, she chose a dowdy long black skirt. WHO WEARS THESE LONG SKIRTS ANYMORE?

  • Tasha

    Just so you know

    Khaki ankle length skirts are “in” when your a Mormon girl from the compound. Dont you watch BIG LOVE?? Nikki wears one almost every episode

  • too far gone

    I re-read Midnight Sun last week. I love Edward’s POV 10 times more than Bella’s. She HAS to finish it, damn it!!

  • well i don’t think twilight is stupid i seen it over 50 times the movie was great and i am so excited to see new moon the only reason i want toto see it is because taylor is goingto lok real sexy in the movie i mean he is a total hotty i love him i am so obbsed with him i would so love to meet his sexiness he was adorable when he was younger i seen his movie sharkboy and lavagirl he was sexy in that to

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons
Attribution-No Derivative Works 3.0
United States License

LTT Privacy Policy

Sponsored by