Posted by themoonisdown on August 9th, 2010
Can you believe that in 20 months of blogging Moon & I have never been gone at the same time? Well, we broke our streak of blogging perfection & we’re BOTH gone this week. Moon is in Africa being selfless caring for kids & I’m sipping champy from a can on a beach in South Carolina (and meeting LTT friend @lula34 for the FIRST time in person!) We were tempted to hang up a “Gone Fishin’ ” sign this week and say “see ya next week” BUT… we resisted. We’ll be bringing you fan letters, some fun posts & mostly just have a simple week. So rest up as we do too and we’ll be back with you next week! Oh- pending comments will be approved but slower than usual- Moon has to send me an owl from Kenya then I use send a telegram to Stephenie Meyer asking her to approve new comments- she’s the only one we trust. You’re in good hands today- Obird Moon’s favorite “boobs in the shoes” girl takes the reigns today and has a shocking confession!
Looks like there's a new kid on the block...
Dear Twilight Saga,
I have a confession to make….you might want to buckle your seat belt. I am fully anticipating being shot at dawn for my crimes, but I have to come clean. The weight of my transgressions are just too much to carry and I just can’t take the guilt any longer. So, here it is. I have been cheating on you. (ducking head to avoid the onslaught of flaming darts from the Twihards) But wait, before you break-up with me please hear me out….I mean we were “on a break” and all. Who was it you ask? Well, if you really MUST know it was Suzanne Collins’ Hunger Games Series. I couldn’t help myself….actually, I blame Janetrigs and Lula with their “Real Books are the ONLY way jazz”….and when the two of them love a book and tell you to read it….YOU DO IT! How many times can one person read #PeetaOwnsMe on twitter and not be curious?? I’m only human after all. I mean even the Queen Bee herself has a gleaming review on the back of the book. I told myself I would just read a few chapters to see if I liked it. I seriously didn’t even think I would like it….there aren’t even any cool hands holding apples on the front cover….it’s just some weird bird with an arrow in it’s mouth. Alas, I was weak and it sucked me in with its amazingness from chapter one.
Now I know this might be a little premature because the Hunger Games trilogy is not yet complete (Mockingjay comes out 8/24/2010 count it down peeps), but I might go as far to say I think this series may be the “next Twilight”. <—insert record screeching, car crashing, baby crying, woman screaming, apocalyptic mass hysteria etc. WAIT….don’t leave….I’m not saying it will REPLACE Twilight, but it just might be the next in line to take the YA fandom by storm. So, being a major Twi fangirl fail I took to to my email to see if I was totally going crazy! Thank goodness I had both Lula and Freya to help me work through the guilt…..proceed with caution and an open mind. PS….slight spoilers ahead.
It's a fandom when the creepy drawings show up.
The first question Twi vs. Hunger Games……and GOOOOOO!!!
Lula: Twilight is the brooding romantic fluff that we all love, the other is young adult literature with a strong heroine & sensitive subject matter with a Sci-Fi bent. There is room for both!
Obird: I completely agree. I mean Twi will ALWAYS be very special, but I was so taken a back by how much I loved Hunger Games. It is the first set of books since Twilight that gave me that “special feeling”….twss.
Lula: Loving another series isn’t a traitorous act. Like ebony & ivory, I don’t see why Twilight and Hunger Games can’t live together in perfect harmony.
Obird: I mean even SM loved them and couldn’t put them down….If that is a “get out of jail free” pass, I don’t know what is.
Then I pulled out the serious guns….aka my tweed jacket and brought Freya into the mix…..
Freya: The Twilight series were the right books at the right time for me. I needed an Edward in my life; that romantic, protective hero who would sacrifice anything for the one he loves. It was very satisfying, and I got hooked into the series.
Obird: Amen lady.
Freya: Hunger Games has not made me obsess like Twi did, but there are elements about it that are superior to Twi.
Obird: Well, I think I might have to join a support group, so give me an example.
Freya: Katniss. Katniss is extraordinary. Bella downplays any talents that she might have (although I do think that Bella is more interesting and talented than she gives herself credit for), but Katniss knows that there are things she can do that are better than others. She’s not vain, she just has some confidence in herself.
Obird: Yes, I totally fangirl over her with the bow and arrows….I wish I had at least some sweet nunchuck skills!! Ok, I’m gonna hit below the belt ladies. Peeta vs. Edward.
Lula: When Katniss kisses Peeta and says that for the first time since they were in the cave together, in the first Games, she “felt that thing again…something stir deep inside. Instead of satisfying me, the kisses have the opposite effect, of making my need greater. I thought I was something of an expert on hunger, but this is an entirely new kind.” That. Right there. That my friend did it for me….slayed me, completed me more than any meadow scene or cold breathy kisses. ‘Cause that right there was freaking amazing….beautiful…frightening….HOT.
I'm team falafel
Freya: Edward vs. Peeta….Must I choose? They’re so different. So I’ll differentiate this way:
I would want Edward:
To do home renovations
To buy me presents
To be on my dodgeball team
To help me do math
I would want Peeta:
To snuggle with
To make secret plans with
To make decisions with (because I would get a say)
To go into business with
Obird: I guess I could settle for a Peeta/Edward sandwhich….heavy on the Peeta ’cause y’all know I’m a sucker for the carbs.
Well, fear not I will always love Twilight and nothing can take that away, but I must say I have enjoyed my torrid affair. Hey, I will even share! If you haven’t read Hunger Games…..GO READ IT!! You will love it….and like Lula says….that’s ok. There is room for both in your heart…I promise….you know ebony and ivory and all that jazz! If you have already read HG what are your thoughts??? Do you want a Peeta/Edward sammy??
Thanks to Freya and Lula for talking me off the ledge and making me want to play dodgeball at 1:30 am….you ladies rule.
Don’t forget “WE WERE ON A BREAK”
So what say you? Do you feel like you’re cheating on Twilight when you read and love other stuff or do you understand there’s room for lots of great stories in your life? Who’s read Hunger Games?
And hey… even though it’s not true… what the heck:
Hey- have you sent in anything for “While Moon was Gone” yet!?
Our internet game is ridiculous: LTR, The Forum, Twitter, The Store
Posted in: A Healthy Debate
, Fan Letters
, fan letter
, healthy debate
, Hunger Games
, Stephenie Meyer
, Suzanne Collins